Welcome back to the MCU Marathon where we are going to look at the first Phase 5 MCU TV show. Will this show have much of a critical impact as its comic-book counterpart with such a fantastic concept about the Skrulls disguising themselves as your favorite characters to invade Earth, or will it be wasted potential just like how the MCU (and Disney) is going through these days? Let’s find out with the new MCU TV series: Secret Invasion.
Pros:
1.) I will give this show this: Secret Invasion is taken completely seriously. I mean that there is no indication of the typical MCU humor that has been plaguing the universe for a long time. I appreciate that Marvel Studios is actually willing to do a more serious tone that has not been around since The Incredible Hulk. It is not going to save this show, but I will give it credit.
2.) If there is one character I actually like, it is Sonya Falsworth (played by Olivia Colman). She is not only shown to be competent in her job compared to Nick Fury (played by Samuel L. Jackson), but she does with a confident smile that makes her seem a bit sadistic considering what she does to the Skrulls. She is what I expected Nick Fury would do in this show with the exception that she is more brutal than I expected. She was cool, and I am somewhat hopeful to see Sonya again assuming that Marvel Studios gets a better-talented crew.
3.) The idea for this show is a fantastic one. In the comics, the Skrulls are invading Earth by disguising themselves as many people from the Avengers to the X-Men to the Fantastic Four to the members of the Sanctum Santorum to the people in the US government to many people on Earth. This causes a huge conundrum in figuring out who is the ally and who is actually a Skrull; which leads to the tagline, “Who do you trust?”
While it is understandable that the show has to take some different liberties due to the changes made with the Skrulls and the MCU itself, it still has a great idea to be a fantastic political thriller that involves the Skrulls infiltrating the governments and causing a war with the entire world. It is unfortunate that it was changed to a smaller scale compared to the original comics, but if the MCU version of Civil War is done well in its own way compared to the comic book Civil War, I am willing to give this version of Secret Invasion a shot…
Cons:
1.) …However, I am sad to say that this show is riddled with issues. Firstly, I believe Nick Fury is completely out of character here. This man is articulate in his planning which may not always go well, but he is determined to keep on going even if he does not make any friends along the way. This show makes him look like an idiot, and many characters keep saying that he lost his touch and is too old for this job. They came up with a reason for the Blip affecting his decisions, but he did not seem to be the type to let that affect him, especially the last time we saw him was him relaxing in a Skrull base. Nick Fury felt neutered here and he became less interesting in the process, and I am not looking forward to how he is done in The Marvels.
2.) The main antagonist, Gravik (played by Kingsley Ben-Adir) is as compelling as Karli Morgenthau in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, and that is not a good thing. These characters wanted a better world for their people, so they are willing to cause trouble in order to make things better for them even if it means killing others in the process. That is not an interesting character, and I am frankly tired of relatable antagonists in the MCU, especially when they are the same motivations as that. I argue that Gravik is even worse than Karli due to the fact that he seems to despise his own race to the point where even some of the Skrulls call it out, and none of them want to leave him. Add that he also makes some dumb decisions like Karli, and he is one of the more forgettable villains despite the actor doing his best.
3.) I am amazed how they used an amazing story and idea in the comics and somehow made it boring. It had a decent start in the first episode, but it went downhill from there with characters that are not that compelling, plotlines that are boring and predictable, twists that people will see coming, questions will be raised on how the Skrulls did not have a bigger role in the MCU considering what they have done (other than they were not created until Captain Marvel), topics that are brought up that does not fit for Nick Fury and this show, and character deaths that I surprisingly do not care about especially since they have been around for a long time. In fact, considering the context of why the Skrulls are attacking Earth, Nick Fury and Captain Marvel did a terrible job helping these people find a new home (you see how much I am not excited for The Marvels?). This should have been an Avengers film that sticks more closely to the comics, but what we got is a boring show that has wasted potential.
Overall:
The Secret Invasion storyline in the comics is one of the most interesting events that happen in Marvel Comics. If you have seen the two videos I posted on the last pro, that event was frightening considering that your favorite superhero could potentially be a Skrull in disguise planning to take over the Earth. With the announcement of a Secret Invasion show, I was slightly excited but worried considering that this is a lower-stakes version of the comics. After painfully watching through all six episodes, I can safely say that this show has completely wasted its potential. Instead of our favorite Marvel superheroes and many parts of Earth being potential Skrulls trying to take over to fulfill a prophecy, we got a boring revenge plot that we have seen many times except the Skrulls are involved now. Nick Fury is not the man we once knew, the Skrulls are barely interesting thanks to the changes from villains to refugees due to Captain Marvel, and a great storyline from the comics has been reduced to a story that might as well have been part of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier (and I thought that show was all right).
The only reason I would recommend this show is that it may be mentioned in the upcoming The Marvels movie, but is anyone looking forward to that? With few exceptions with its films and TV shows, the MCU’s future is looking bleak, and this so-called Secret Invasion is hardly one at all.
Skip It