Pros:
1.) If I have to pick one or two good things about this movie, it does have great visuals and direction. From the costume/environmental designs to the cinematography, director Zack Snyder knows how to shoot a film for the most part. When he has a good shot that pairs with an action moment, he will show it off. Zack Snyder knows how to make killer visuals despite his huge writing flaws…
Cons:
1.) …Speaking of writing flaws, if you thought the first movie was bad, wait until you get to the second movie. I should have pointed this out in the first movie review, but the writing and the story are absolutely atrocious. From the world-building to the characters, not only are some of these plot points and parts of the world unoriginal, but the characters are easily the most forgettable people ever considering the failure to characterize them properly and gaping plot holes that will make you receive a migraine. I still do not understand why this galactic empire is interested in this one small farmland that produces grain when they could have tried other planets/worlds that could create the same thing. Not to mention the Seven Samurai/The Magnificent Seven plot line of a small group of village people fighting against a big group of criminals does not work when those small group of people are fighting a galactic army with tanks. There are bigger problems in the story and the writing like the characters, but I will focus on that in the last con.
2.) The action scenes are terrible, too. It is not because it is unclear to watch due to shaky cam or bad cinematography, it is because the audience can see the horrible action choreography (not helped by the slow-motion). There are so many moments where the main characters could have been shot and killed, but the villains are so bad at their shots that the Stormtroopers would be amazed. Anytime a major character is on a battlefield with enemy soldiers right in front of them, the movie cuts to another shot in front of these characters to avoid seeing these soldiers aiming at them when they should have. In fact, some fights have enemies that should be shooting when all they do is run toward them, something that a swordfighter would do, not a gunman. However, the only fight scene I liked was the last battle between Kora (played by Sofia Boutella) and Atticus Noble (played by Ed Skrein) since it does look cool what is happening during that fight.
I cannot stress this enough: if this movie makes the Galactic Stormtroopers look good, you know you messed up.
3.) Let’s talk about the characters if you remember them. None of them are fleshed out well; their characterization (if most of them had any) is so sloppy that I cannot believe anyone wrote this and thought it was a good idea. The biggest example of how poor their characterization is is a scene where the major characters are having some R&R and explaining their backstories to gain each other’s trust…two problems: it is far too late for anyone to care and it would have been better if this was done in the last movie where the writers could have dispersed their backstories throughout different points in that movie…like Watchmen. Let me highlight the poor characters with two more examples: Nemesis (played by Doona Bae) befriends a young boy on the farm, but these two barely interact (all they do is share looks), which does not work considering what happens to Nemesis in the climax and how that boy reacted to it. Kora has a romantic relationship with Gunnar (played by Michiel Huisman), which I do not understand since she has not shown any interest in him in the last movie (as far as I remember, that was not good either) despite Gunnar having romantic interests with Kora.
There are more I can point out like Jimmy (voiced by Anthony Hopkins) could single-handedly take on the evil imperial army by himself or something about a princess that is the movie’s obvious attempt to sequel-bait. I am sure you understand how these characters are wasted at best and completely forgettable at worst.
Overall:
Part 2 of Zack Snyder’s R-rated Star Wars movie idea is finally released with little fanfare, and there is a good reason why. It is bad when I say that Disney of all companies made the correct choice to refuse this idea into the Star Wars universe. The characters are forgettable, the world-building is stupid, the writing is non-sensical, the action scenes are poorly coordinated, and everything about this movie is doomed to fail. I want to support Zack Snyder on his Star Wars project considering how poorly Star Wars is going through these days, but I cannot do that when he makes terrible ideas like the Rebel Moon movies. I cannot recommend this and its predecessor to anyone; it is a movie series that proves the Force was never strong with Zack Snyder.
2/10